Home » Thrift Store Makeovers » Shutter Mail Organizer

Shutter Mail Organizer

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

I’ll make a shutter mail organizer from a thrifted $5 shutter for this month’s Thrift Store Decor project. This project is unique because it’s very, very simple. Generally, when I do a shutter project, I reach for plywood and my saws. However, I opted for cardboard and hot glue to make this shutter mail organizer easy enough for anyone to make! That is one of the many reasons I love doing this monthly challenge. It makes me KISS–keep it simple, silly! Originally, the phrase was stupid, and came from the US Navy in the 60’s. But for me, I’ll change it to silly. 😉

Shutter Mail Organizer
$5 thrift store shutter

Have you ever seen such a shutter? I really liked its size for this project. But it sure was nasty! However, the price was right!!!

Related Content: See more shutter projects here


Don’t forget to check out all the other great thrift store makeovers at the bottom of this post.

Visit the My Repurposed Life Amazon Store to shop my favorite items.

Supplies & Materials to Make a Shutter Mail Organizer




  1. Gather Supplies for Cleaning

    Before you can paint, you must remove unknown dirt, grime, nicotine, etc.

    how to clean shutter

  2. Brush on Deglosser

    Because you never know what grime is actually on your project, it’s a good idea to use a deglosser. It not only cleans grease but dulls the shine, making your project ready for paint.brush on deglosser

  3. Scrub Project

    Using a pot scrubber, clean your project (shutter mail organizer). scrub away dirt

  4. Rinse

    If you lifted a lot of dirt, grime, or nicotine, it’s important to rinse your project well. You can even use a hose for large projects, as I did on my antique table makeover. On this smaller project, because it was cold, I opted for a tub of water to rinse away all the dirt.

  5. Allow the Shutter to Dry

    Because it was a cold but sunny day, I simply stood the shutter on end to allow it to dry thoroughly.

  6. Paint Shutter Mail Organizer

    Use your favorite paint. I couldn’t decide between Black or White, so I compromised and went with HTP Cobblestone. I truly love this small paintbrush. I’ve had it for years, and it cleans up nicely and doesn’t leave brush strokes.paint shutter mail organizer

  7. Apply 2 coats of paint

    All in all, I generally do 2 1/2 coats of paint. The first coat is very light, the second coat is for great coverage, the half coat is a touch-up coat, painting only where necessary.

  8. Mark Shutter for Applying Hot Glue

    In order to keep letters, cards, etc, from falling through the slats, I opted to apply hot glue 1/3 and 2/3 down the back. Notice the blue Sharpie marks. Those were to remind me where to apply the hot glue.
    Because the hot glue sets up quickly, I worked in sections attaching the cardboard.

  9. Continue to Apply Hot Glue

    Carefully, I worked my way down the back of the shutter mail organizer, applying hot glue to the sides and across four slats. (top, two slats equally spaced and the bottom)

  10. Cardboard Attached to Back of Shutter

    Voila! The cardboard is secure. This is where you could stop if it’s your own project. However, I’ll be selling this shutter mail organizer, so I wanted to give it a more finished look.

  11. Cover the Back of the Shutter with Fabric

    This is totally optional. You could use contact paper. I chose to use the same fabric I used on a drawer jewelry organizer.
    First, I tore the fabric to get a straight line, then continued to tear each side until I got a good fit.
    After that, I folded and pinned a little hem all the way around.
    Then, I ironed the fabric and the hem.
    Finally, I hot glued all around the edges, a little at a time until the fabric covered the cardboard.

  12. Touch Up Paint

    Some hot glue oozed out as I was securing the fabric. I used an exacto knife to cut away the glue, then used my paintbrush to touch up any boo-boos.

  13. Add D Rings for Hanging

    I buy D rings in bulk on Amazon. Even though these have one screw, they are very strong and secure. After securing them, I loosened the screw slightly in order to allow the d ring to move, making it easier to hang on the wall.

  14. Attach Hooks (optional)

    Hooks are handy, not just for keys but also sunglasses, masks, leashes, and more! I bought these hooks on a trip last summer. I loved their look. Upon installing them, I was in LOVE with them even more. Not only their simple look but the ease of installing them. Having only one screw makes them oh-so easy to get straight! attach hooks to shutter mail organizer

  15. Voila! The project is “almost” complete!

    The Welcome sign is metal. I attached it with some double sticky mounting tape. It was easily removed, and I added a Welcome sentiment with chalk paste and a transfer.repurposed shutter mail organizer

Pin the D Ring Tip!

So, I found some similar hooks on Amazon. Some are large hooks, and the others are much smaller hooks. I wish I had bought more on my trip to New Hampshire!

Shutter Mail Organizer

So, I’m wondering. Which Welcome do you like better? Is it the metal sign or the stencil/transfer? I have a good friend who has issues with fonts. What say you?

Finally, it’s time to check out the rest of the projects from the thrift store team.

How To Spray Paint Wood Furniture

Upcycle Vintage Metal Library Stool

How to Upcycle a Floral Centerpiece

Shutter Mail Organizer (you are here)

Upcycling Plates into a Snowman

Pine Tree Embroidery for Winter Decor

How to Easily Paint Wicker

Thrifted Wooden Box Boho Makeover

Upcycled Stepladder Decorating Ideas

17 Comments

    1. Thank you Brenda! Did you see that I got the hooks for this in New Hampshire? Yep, Rochester!

      Thanks for stopping by and taking the time to leave a comment.

      gail

  1. Such a great makeover, makes you wonder where a little shutter that size was in a house? Maybe a small bathroom?
    Such a pretty color and that fabric is adorable!
    Both signs are cute but I love that the metal since it’s a little bit bigger

    1. Thank you Kristin for your sweet comment. I think it may have been half a small door, cut in half? But for $5, I wasn’t questioning it. 🙂

      gail

  2. Ooh, what is your deglosser of choice? I definitely have some pieces that need that before I craft with them!

    And what a perfectly sized shutter- you’re right, it’s such an odd but ideal shape for a project like this! Maybe it was from one of those odd-shaped above-the-garage attic windows?

    1. I use Heirloom Traditions paint and deglosser. It’s so much easier than sanding, especially on a project like this. I’m thinking the shutter was cut in half from some other door or something?

      gail

  3. I love both fonts but maybe the metal better because it is more whimsical!
    Smaller shutters have so much more potential. There are so many tips and so much info in this post. Loved it!

    1. Thanks Sue! Happy you enjoyed my project this month. I love, love, love the hooks! My friend must not be very whimsical, because she really it particular about fonts. 🙂

      gail

    1. I’m so surprised y’all like the metal sign the best! I’ll have to use it soon on a future project. My items haven’t been selling very much lately. It’s funny, that when I really love a project, it isn’t popular at the booth. Go figure!

      gail

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.