Home » DIY » Brick Fireplace Makeover

Brick Fireplace Makeover

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

1980’s Ugly Brick Fireplace Makeover with lumber and paint.

I’m so happy my brick fireplace makeover is done! It makes me smile every time I look at it.

1980 Dark Brick Fireplace with Stone Mantel

Wow! Isn’t this brick fireplace makeover amazing? How did I put up with that look for so many years?

brick fireplace makeover

Fresh White Fireplace and Mantel

How to Faux Wood Mantel

How to Paint a Brick Fireplace

Meeting Challenges Head On

This is the right side of the hearth before. . .

After I enclosed the hearth with underlayment. That ugly floor area is no longer visible!

A look at how I used the thin plywood to make a new facade over the brick.

After which I added a 1×6 for the brick fireplace makeover.

Boxing in a Stone Mantel & Hearth with Thin Plywood

I love the new look so much!

I always,   a.l.w.a.y.s. hated the concrete hearth. It was suppose to be stone, not two slabs of concrete with a seam.

Adding and securing wood trim pieces.

White Brick Fireplace with Black Firebox

Please remember I am not a decorator. I used what I have at the house to show off my new mantel. I’m sure I will change it up many, many times before I settle in to something I really like.

Below is the cost break down. It’s more than I expected, but overall, I guess it’s not too bad.

Cost of Brick Fireplace Makeover

Would I do it again?! You bet! I was so tired of all that dirty brick and concrete!

  • Crown Molding (mantel)  8.96
  • Crown Molding (ceiling)  12.32
  • Lauan 2 sheets  10.28 ea  20.56
  • 1/2 x 3/4 Molding (2 pieces for mantel, 1 for hearth) 8’, 8’, 9’ .42 lf  10.50
  • 2×4’s 9’ free (curb finds) -0-
  • 1×4’s (3) 6’ 2.78 ea 8.34
  • Screen pine trim 24’, 40’   .59 lf  37.76
  • 1×6 (2) to cover sides of brick on left and right sides  6’  5.27 ea  10.54
  • Quarter round  9’  .42 lf  3.78
  • Kilz  1 gallon  12.00 (estimated)  12.00
  • Semi gloss paint  1 gallon  12.00 (estimated)  12.00
  • Black paint  1 qt  7.55  .55
  • Wooden applique  free (thanks Jamie)  0-
  • Vent 5.00
  • Glass shades for light fixtures  2 free (thanks Sherry) -0-
  • Misc (caulk, spackling,nails, wood glue, liquid nails)

If you have any questions, comments please contact me through my e-mail or a comment below.

Updates Through the Years

EDITED TO ADD:  As of Summer 2010, my fireplace mantel looks like this:

The fireplace screen? It was brass, and I painted it! See how to paint a brass fireplace screen.

This has to be my favorite project of all time. I wanted a change for so long and I did it all myself (from scratch). It still makes me smile when I look at it!

No fireplace, no problem: Make a Faux Fireplace Mantel

fireplace-makeover-Christmas-mantel

Christmas 2015 See the easy shutter fireplace screen here.

How about another update? Summer 2019, AFTER I installed floating laminate flooring! See the easy window project here.

Pin It

You can check out my other posts here:
how to faux wood mantel
painted brick fireplace

give a brick fireplace a wooden facade

fireplace pt 4

adding trim to a wooden fireplace facade

If your fireplace just needs a paint update, be sure to check out Thrift Diving’s How to Paint an Old Brick Fireplace.

73 Comments

  1. This is so cool! I dream of re-doing my mantle but have always thought it would be way to expensive. I love your little spreadsheet of costs because it showed me this project doesn’t have to be too far off.

  2. Oh. My. Gosh. It is JUST gorgeous! I can’t believe you knocked out such a massive project in such a short time and for so little! Way to go!!
    I hate my fireplace–will you come here next?!

  3. Gail, Your fireplace makeover is amazing! I love what you did to update and change from the drab to the dazzling. You must be so elated with the results. You give us so much hope…that we can accomplish just about anything no matter the size of the project.
    ~judi 😉

  4. Gail, it’s beautiful! You did such a wonderful job, and I think that $149 is an incredible bottom line! So happy for you. Now you can look at it and think happy thoughts instead of of dark, dirty thoughts. Uh, wait. You know what I mean. (I’m such a dork! That came out wrong. 😉

  5. Wow! you did an incredible job! Not sure how I stumbled onto your blog, but been blog stalking you throught your process of rebuilding your fireplace. It’s beautiful. LOVE! Will be checking out some of your other projects. Thanks for sharing!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.